Skip to content
Grand Jury Hub

Mariposa County Civil Grand Jury

2023-2024: from findings to follow-through

Overview

Explore the jury’s recommendations, read matching agency responses, and join the discussion. Everything in this cycle is connected to its original source.

Recommendations & responses

Every recommendation made by the jury, with matching agency responses alongside it.

Recommendations & responses

Showing 41 of 41 recommendations

Jump to recommendation

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation

10 recommendations

Recommendation R1

JCFHD Board should be more diligent in vetting CEO candidates.

2 responses · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Will implement a more robust process with greater HR support.

Read official response · PDF page 21
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Describes recruiter and HR planning, vetting of the interim CEO, and expected involvement of staff, providers, and the community in recruitment beginning fall/winter 2025–2026.

Read official response · PDF page 24

Recommendation R2

JCFHD Board should be more diligent in financial review of the Healthcare District.

2 responses · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Reports selecting Warbird Consulting Partners to verify accounts, payroll, and statements and provide regular reports during a nine-month contract.

Read official response · PDF page 21
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Says it is building long-term oversight and expects the consulting firm to report in summer 2025.

Read official response · PDF page 25

Recommendation R3

JCFHD should review existing vetting procedures for hiring C-suite level management within 6 months.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Will task HR with policy review, use counsel as needed, and require progress reports to meet the jury’s six-month timeframe.

Read official response · PDF page 21

Recommendation R4

JCFHD Board of Directors should ensure adherence to existing vetting procedures for hiring C-suite level management.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Distinguishes Board responsibility for the CEO from HR responsibility for other executives and promises adherence.

Read official response · PDF page 21

Recommendation R5

Immediately, JCFHD should make it a priority to work together and function cohesively as a team.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency position unclear

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and will make teamwork a priority.

Read official response · PDF page 21

Recommendation R6

Immediately, JCFHD Board of Directors should ensure procedures for financial oversight of CEO are being followed at all times.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency position unclear

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says it has made the recommendation a priority.

Read official response · PDF page 21

Recommendation R7

JCFHD Board of Directors should review the organizational structure of the Healthcare District, specifically related to financial responsibilities of the CEO, COO and CFO with the intention of creating more financial oversight within their purview, within 9 months.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and promises completion within the jury’s nine-month timeframe.

Read official response · PDF page 22

Recommendation R8

Immediately, JCFHD Board of Directors should review and establish mechanisms to guarantee timely production of accurate audits.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency position unclear

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says the recommendation is a priority.

Read official response · PDF page 22

Recommendation R9

Immediately, the JCFHD Board of Directors should continue with the reimplementation of the JCFHD compliance hotline.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says work is underway on this priority.

Read official response · PDF page 22

Recommendation R10

JCFHD Board of Directors should practice due diligence with the Board Clerk to make certain all meeting minutes are recorded and kept as required by law.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency position unclear

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says the matter has always been and remains a priority.

Read official response · PDF page 22

Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization

5 recommendations

Recommendation R1

Board of Supervisors should direct all department directors and managers to provide a review of essential policies and procedures within six (6) months.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Plans completion in twelve months rather than six.

Read official response · PDF page 9

Recommendation R2

Board of Supervisors should identify a central point of contact for review of necessary written policies and procedures within six (6) months. This should include review of policies and procedures to guarantee compatibility and consistency across departments.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and assigns responsibility to departments and the County Administrative Officer.

Read official response · PDF page 9

Recommendation R3

Working with the Chief Administrative Officer, the Board of Supervisors should develop procedures that establish regular communication between departments within six (6) months.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 10

Recommendation R4

Board of Supervisors, working with Human Resources, should make efforts to minimize the loss of institutional knowledge by facilitating a transition period where outgoing staff overlap with their successors.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency says implemented

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Reports use of existing overhiring guidelines, sometimes allowing ninety days or more of overlap, while noting practical challenges.

Read official response · PDF page 10

Recommendation R5

Board of Supervisors, working with Human Resources, should review and develop standardized training opportunities for all County employees within six (6) months.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Plans Internal Services and a two-part approach to core and role-specific training over twelve to eighteen months.

Read official response · PDF page 10

County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024

5 recommendations

Recommendation R1

The Auditor should establish written procedures for how audits for the fiscal year shall be completed on a timely basis within the next three (3) months.

1 response · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 6

Recommendation R2

The Auditor should complete two (2) management/leadership trainings totaling a minimum of 16 hours within 12 months. Successful completion of this activity shall be documented with the 2024-25 Civil Grand Jury within 30 days of completion.

1 response · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 6

Recommendation R3

Board of Supervisors should establish procedures for regular financial review, including "check ins," for the completion of annual fiscal year audits within six (6) months.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Says procedures for regular reviews are being established.

Read official response · PDF page 11

Recommendation R4

Within six (6) months, the Auditor and Assistant CAO/Finance should participate in a facilitated debrief of activity and decisions reached between their offices over the last two (2) years.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 6

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 11
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 6

Recommendation R5

After completion of R4, the Auditor and Assistant CAO/Finance will develop a plan to continue a strong working relationship

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 6

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and calls a good working relationship essential.

Read official response · PDF page 11
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 7

Continued Technology and Software Lessons

5 recommendations

Recommendation R1

Within six months, the Auditor, CAO and Assistant CAO/finance should complete a plan for elimination of AS400 from 90% of County activities by the end of FY 2025-26.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 12
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 7

Recommendation R2

The County should examine methods of eliminating double entry in County functions within six (6) months.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 12
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 7

Recommendation R3

The County should allow for ample time to implement Tyler while being aggressive about complete implementation of the new system.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and describes a phased transition expected to take up to three years.

Read official response · PDF page 12

Recommendation R4

The County should fully implement the Oracle Accounts Receivable module within one (1) year, in addition to any other areas of incomplete implementation.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Reports meetings have begun and promises implementation by June 2025.

Read official response · PDF page 12
Mariposa County Auditor
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Auditor: Will implement the recommendation.

Read official response · PDF page 7

Recommendation R5

The County should review use of private cell phones for work activities.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Promises a review within six months, referring to the security review under F4.

Read official response · PDF page 12

Complaints and Code Compliance

2 recommendations

Recommendation R1

The County should codify code enforcement standards and provide clearly written procedures for case management through the Code Compliance Advisory Committee with one (1) year.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Complaints and Code Compliance · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Reports May 2024 Board direction and work with the advisory committee on a four-part program and Tyler workflows, planned for FY 2024–2025.

Read official response · PDF page 13

Recommendation R2

The Board of Supervisors should require that uniform standards for managing complaints specific to County operations be established within one (1) year.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Complaints and Code Compliance · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 13

Development Services

6 recommendations

Recommendation R1

The Planning Department, Building Department, and Environmental Health Division should create informational resources to help the community understand permitting processes for Mariposa County within one (1) year.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Says the CAO has been tasked with an education series on services, legislation, and procedures.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Recommendation R2

Immediately, effort should be made to address staff shortages in the Environmental Health Division

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Recommendation R3

Immediately, effort should be made to address the Planning Department Deputy Director and other staff vacancies.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Reports a staffing strategy, solicitation for contract planning support, and review of deputy-level needs.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Recommendation R4

Working with Administration, the interim Building Department Director should evaluate and establish an effective reflection of the department's budget as an enterprise within six (6) months.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees and assigns the budget review to the CAO as part of organizational review within six months.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Recommendation R5

Immediately, policies and procedures should be written for the Departments of Planning and Building and the Division of Environmental Health.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Says Development Services policies are being created with Tyler support and will be routinely updated.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Recommendation R6

Within one (1) year, written policies and procedures for the Departments of Planning and Building and the Division of Environmental Health should be reviewed for consistency and accuracy across the units.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF pages 4–5

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency position unclear

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and says procedures should be reviewed annually for law and Tyler-related changes.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Evaluation of Department Directors

1 recommendation

Recommendation R1

The Board of Supervisors should create clear written procedures for the evaluation of department directors within the next 12 months.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Evaluation of Department Directors · PDF page 2

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees and links procedure development to the organizational study’s proposed CAO reporting structure (continued on packet page 16).

Read official response · PDF page 15

Understanding Conflict of Interest and Employee Abstention

1 recommendation

Recommendation R1

The County should create a written policy and procedure accurately reflecting when any official or representative of the County must declare recusal.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Understanding Conflict of Interest and Employee Abstention · PDF pages 1–2

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency declines implementation

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Declines as unwarranted because an existing code applies; promises to post it more prominently as a standalone document.

Read official response · PDF page 16

Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD

2 recommendations

Recommendation R1

JCFHD and Mariposa County Board of Supervisors should each create unique procedures for staff to report issues of non-compliance.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and promises training on existing grievance, whistleblower, and non-compliance procedures.

Read official response · PDF page 17
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency plans to implement

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Says the compliance officer is already creating procedures.

Read official response · PDF page 23

Recommendation R2

JCFHD and Mariposa County Board of Supervisors should establish procedures that create more strategic engagement practices with external consultants to include pre-contract negotiations, clear and timely project review mechanisms and post contract review.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and says the CAO has been tasked with a robust contract review.

Read official response · PDF page 17
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors
Agency says implemented

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Says existing practices cover negotiation, timely project review, and post-contract review.

Read official response · PDF page 23

Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility

2 recommendations

Recommendation R1

Replace the HVAC system in all areas that are necessary as soon as possible.

2 responses · Mariposa County Sheriff's Office · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility · PDF page 2

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Sheriff's Office
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Sheriff's Office: Reports completed plans, with permit review and bid advertisement next.

Read official response · PDF page 1
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees; the F1 paragraph on the same page describes assessment and bidding work.

Read official response · PDF page 17

Recommendation R2

Continue to investigate and pursue ways of maximizing shared staff space while maintaining professional best practice.

2 responses · Mariposa County Sheriff's Office · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility · PDF page 2

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Sheriff's Office
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Sheriff's Office: Reports storage-container purchases to free an internal room and design work for an extension; funding for the extension remains unidentified.

Read official response · PDF page 2
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and refers to continuing pursuit of additional grants.

Read official response · PDF page 17

Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity

2 recommendations

Recommendation R1

County Counsel should develop and provide educational material for Board of Supervisors, Directors and staff for how to affectively work with civil grand jury in the next six months,

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency plans to implement

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Says the recommendation will be implemented within six months.

Read official response · PDF page 18

Recommendation R2

Board of Supervisors should welcome comment from any named invited responses.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View recommendation and responses

Jury report: Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors
Agency declines implementation

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees and will continue gathering feedback into a single response letter.

Read official response · PDF page 18

Findings

The jury’s formal findings, with source citations and any recorded responses.

Findings & responses

Showing 37 of 37 findings

Jump to finding

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation

7 findings

Finding F1

Significant instability in Board leadership (3 board resignations, and 6 interim/new Chief Executive Officers since 2022) and Executive C-Suite management led to the public's diminished confidence in the John C. Fremont Healthcare District.

2 responses · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF pages 2–3

Permanent link
Official responses
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Partly agrees; says only one resignation occurred during the current term and explains interim-CEO appointments and rural recruitment difficulties.

Read official response · PDF page 19
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Partly agrees; describes stable Board membership since November 2024, two new members, and early work on permanent CEO recruitment.

Read official response · PDF page 24

Finding F2

The JCFHD Board of Directors withheld information between themselves leading to individual discontent and poor decision making.

2 responses · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Disagrees, saying information was withheld only as necessary to comply with the Brown Act and citing Board training.

Read official response · PDF page 20
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Disagrees, citing renewed annual Brown Act and Code of Conduct training and use of public meetings for quorum decisions.

Read official response · PDF page 24

Finding F3

The JCFHD Board of Directors did not have an opportunity to vet interim CEO which led to a longer period until issues could be legally responded to and resolved.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees; says the previous Board vetted the inherited interim CEO and an outside agency vetted the last permanent hire.

Read official response · PDF page 20

Finding F4

JCFHD Human Resources did not properly vet executive level positions leading to instability at C-suite level.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says previous HR personnel did not share vetting with the Board.

Read official response · PDF page 20

Finding F5

Multiple CEOs exceeded contractual spending limits without JCFHD Board notification eroding inherent checks and balances in organizational structure and straining the hospital financially.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says the Board acted swiftly to remove the CEOs.

Read official response · PDF page 20

Finding F6

The JCFHD found themselves behind in regular financial audits jeopardizing funding from governmental agencies.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says inherited audits were completed the previous fall and monthly-financial delays were resolved after a CEO departure.

Read official response · PDF page 20

Finding F7

Work and dialogue outside of regular, special, and emergency meetings between directors of the JCFHD puts the Board at risk of violating Brown Act practices.

1 response · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees such conduct risks violations but disputes that the Board engaged in it; says it minimizes outside dialogue and will continue training (continued on the next packet page).

Read official response · PDF page 20

Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization

4 findings

Finding F1

Lack of written policies and procedures across multiple Mariposa County departments make it difficult for staff to perform duties efficiently and for new department managers to lead effectively.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees but cites existing policies, including 258 at HHSA, and identifies access as the problem.

Read official response · PDF page 8

Finding F2

Inconsistent communication between Mariposa County departments has led to a lack of continuity and transparency in County services.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees, cites Guidehouse’s organizational assessment, and plans reorganization in FY 2024–2025; continuation says staff may approach Board members.

Read official response · PDF page 8

Finding F3

Loss of and anticipated loss of institutional knowledge across multiple Mariposa County departments has created and is expected to continue to create large gaps in County operations and efficiency.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees while saying gaps can be temporary and successors may improve old processes.

Read official response · PDF page 9

Finding F4

Lack of training opportunities across multiple Mariposa County departments and for all level of job classifications leads to work errors, department inefficiencies and missed opportunities to learn best practices.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees about gaps in online training but cites hands-on programs, 27 CSAC credential participants, and January 2024 FRISK training.

Read official response · PDF page 9

County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024

5 findings

Finding F1

The annual financial audit for FY 2021-22 has not been completed for Mariposa County leading to incorrect fiscal year budget projections for FY 2023-24.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View finding and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 10
Mariposa County Auditor

Mariposa County Auditor: Agrees with the finding.

Read official response · PDF page 6

Finding F2

Incorrect FY 2022-23 budget projections and untimely communication led to a later than normal mid-year budget review.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees; says the midyear review did not occur and balancing adjustments waited until February 20, 2024 because opening balances arrived in January.

Read official response · PDF page 10

Finding F3

The accounting error of reserve contributions resulted in necessary emergency budget reconciliation and redistribution across County departments.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees; says contributions followed the budget but balance-sheet accounting made the lower FY24 opening balance unexpected.

Read official response · PDF page 11

Finding F4

Daily activities not completed and left incomplete over a long time put the County at risk, as shown with the lack of a completed audit for FY 2021-22.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View finding and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 11
Mariposa County Auditor

Mariposa County Auditor: Agrees with the finding.

Read official response · PDF page 6

Finding F5

Working relationships between the Auditor's Office and County Administration were negatively affected by the combination of miscalculated budget for FY 23-24 projections and lack of completed FY 21-22 audit.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View finding and responses

Jury report: County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · PDF page 5

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees and attributes strain to Oracle implementation and missed budget and audit deadlines.

Read official response · PDF page 11
Mariposa County Auditor

Mariposa County Auditor: Agrees with the finding.

Read official response · PDF page 6

Continued Technology and Software Lessons

4 findings

Finding F1

Incomplete implementation of Oracle and continued use of multiple software systems has necessitated double entry of data, which has led to increased rates of error and time dedicated to data entry in County services

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · Mariposa County Auditor

View finding and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees; says duplicate entry remains but has been reduced in many areas.

Read official response · PDF page 11
Mariposa County Auditor

Mariposa County Auditor: Agrees.

Read official response · PDF page 7

Finding F2

Tyler's platform limitations and rigorous schedule for release raises concerns about the success of implementation

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees, citing a carefully developed schedule, dedicated transition team, and lessons from prior implementations.

Read official response · PDF page 11

Finding F3

Technology and software support, training and assistance is lacking, leading to a slow transition to Oracle.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees, distinguishing uneven adoption from the availability of training, help sessions, support email, and implementation-partner assistance.

Read official response · PDF page 12

Finding F4

Multiple County employees use personal phones for county work, Multiple Factor Authentication, and communication, which raises concerns about security.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Continued Technology and Software Lessons · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees, cites a 2012 security policy, and promises a six-month review of approvals and safeguards.

Read official response · PDF page 12

Complaints and Code Compliance

2 findings

Finding F1

A lack of clearly written procedures and standards for management and enforcement of code compliance cases has led to an overwhelming number of active cases, inconsistent follow-through and compromised code enforcement.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Complaints and Code Compliance · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees; says staffing capacity and turnover also contribute to the backlog.

Read official response · PDF page 12

Finding F2

Inconsistent management of complaints between County departments has led to public frustration and disempowerment in providing feedback on county processes.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Complaints and Code Compliance · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and promises a CAO reorganization proposal within six months.

Read official response · PDF page 13

Development Services

6 findings

Finding F1

Inconsistencies in the permitting process have led to confusion and complaints from the community.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees and identifies retirements and turnover as additional causes; points to Tyler as a remedy.

Read official response · PDF page 13

Finding F2

Staff shortages in Environmental Health have created an overwhelming workload, putting the County at risk for timely identification of environmental hazards.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Somewhat agrees, cites nine allocations and two vacancies as of July 11, 2024, and suggests time management also contributes to delays.

Read official response · PDF page 14

Finding F3

The continued vacancy in the position of Deputy Director and other staff positions for the Planning Department is having a direct effect on time management of County projects and timely department communications.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees with clarification that mid-level, senior, and entry-level vacancies constrain processing and communication.

Read official response · PDF page 14

Finding F4

Building Department budget does not effectively reflect the department's revenue and expense streams as an enterprise fund, making the Building Department budget unclear and confusing.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF pages 3–4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees that ten years of budgets lack clear revenue and expense detail and points to possible AS400-to-Oracle transfer issues.

Read official response · PDF page 14

Finding F5

Although lumped together under the term Development Services, the Departments of Planning and Building, and the Division of Environmental Health have separate procedures for how work is managed leading to confusion, lack of efficiency and complaints from the community.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and cites the early-2024 Guidehouse study supporting consolidation or unified policies.

Read official response · PDF page 14

Finding F6

Lack of formal written policies and procedures for the Planning and Building Departments and the Division of Environmental Health has led to confusion in completing job tasks among employees, affecting quality and timeliness of work in Development Services.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Development Services · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and acknowledges that missing written procedures created challenges in some areas.

Read official response · PDF page 14

Evaluation of Department Directors

1 finding

Finding F1

The Board of Supervisors does not have clear written procedure for consistent, measured performance evaluation of department directors.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Evaluation of Department Directors · PDF page 2

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees and says evaluations will be formalized within twelve months.

Read official response · PDF page 15

Understanding Conflict of Interest and Employee Abstention

1 finding

Finding F1

Lack of clear, concise policy and procedure regarding recusal and appearance of conflict of interest puts the County at risk for increased complaints, possible legal action, and overall poor appearance for County operations.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Understanding Conflict of Interest and Employee Abstention · PDF page 1

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees, cites the regulatory code, a February 6, 2024 update, and biennial ethics training.

Read official response · PDF page 16

Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD

2 findings

Finding F1

JCFHD and Mariposa County do not have their own clearly defined whistleblower policies making it difficult for staff to report issues of non-compliance.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD · PDF pages 3–4

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees, citing a whistleblower form posted in County breakrooms and verification by labor unions.

Read official response · PDF page 16
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Agrees and says its compliance officer is establishing policies and procedures.

Read official response · PDF page 22

Finding F2

JCFHD and Mariposa County do not have clear procedures for establishing, managing and reviewing contracts with external consultants which often leads to contract delays, deliverables that do not meet original objectives and excessive financial costs.

2 responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD · PDF page 4

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees, citing a 2022 purchasing policy amended in 2023 and County Counsel/CAO review.

Read official response · PDF page 16
John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors: Disagrees and says clear contract procedures already exist.

Read official response · PDF page 22

Observations of Elections

1 finding

Finding F1

Elections in Mariposa County are administered professionally and are securely, enabling citizens to feel comfortable about election integrity.

No response recorded

View finding and responses

Jury report: Observations of Elections · PDF page 1

Permanent link
Official responses
No response recorded
A matching agency response has not been added to Grand Jury Hub. This does not establish whether a response was submitted or is overdue.

Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility

2 findings

Finding F1

The detention center HVAC system poses a challenge to detention center management, contributing to uncomfortable environmental exposure for inmates, staff and visitors.

2 responses · Mariposa County Sheriff's Office · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility · PDF page 2

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Sheriff's Office

Mariposa County Sheriff's Office: Accepts and reports HVAC/electrical engineering plans completed July 5, 2024 with Public Works and KPA Group.

Read official response · PDF page 1
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees, describes assessment for a formal bid process, and says this work should be completed in six months.

Read official response · PDF page 17

Finding F2

Available administration office space to staff ratio is small, creating cramped and shared quarters for staff.

2 responses · Mariposa County Sheriff's Office · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility · PDF page 2

Permanent link
Official responses
Mariposa County Sheriff's Office

Mariposa County Sheriff's Office: Accepts and describes purchased storage containers and a proposed extension to the north lawn.

Read official response · PDF page 2
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Agrees, cites Sheriff and HHSA grant applications and completed site plans, and describes State grant delays.

Read official response · PDF page 17

Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity

2 findings

Finding F1

There is no training for County staff on how to respond to requests and or inquiries from the Civil Grand Jury in compliance with the California Penal Code leading to inconsistencies from year to year in responses to Civil Grand Jury final reports

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Partly agrees that training is absent but disputes the causal claim, distinguishing investigation interviews from responses after a final report.

Read official response · PDF page 17

Finding F2

Board of Supervisors has blocked invited responses from Civil Grand Jury giving an impression of not wishing to hear from other individuals.

1 response · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

View finding and responses

Jury report: Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity · PDF page 3

Permanent link
Official response
Mariposa County Board of Supervisors

Mariposa County Board of Supervisors: Disagrees, saying separate responses are redundant and that invited officials’ feedback is incorporated in its letter.

Read official response · PDF page 18

Questions

Editorial discussion prompts inspired by the reports. These are separate from the jury’s formal findings and recommendations.

Civic question

What information should the hospital Board share to demonstrate dependable hiring, financial review, and executive oversight?

The jury links leadership instability and weaknesses in oversight to public confidence and recommends more diligent hiring and financial review.
Why this matters
Reliable oversight matters to residents who depend on local healthcare and contribute to its funding.

Supporting report

John C. Fremont Healthcare District Investigation · Findings F2–F7 and Recommendations R1–R3

Civic question

What should a consistent director evaluation process measure about public service and departmental performance?

The jury recommends clear written procedures for evaluating department directors within twelve months.
Why this matters
Residents benefit when leadership expectations are clear and problems receive follow-up.

Supporting report

Evaluation of Department Directors · Finding F1 and Recommendation R1

Civic question

How should the County explain when officials must step aside and how work continues after a recusal?

The jury calls for a written policy explaining when County representatives must declare recusal.
Why this matters
Understandable procedures help residents assess impartiality without assuming that every disagreement is a conflict.

Supporting report

Understanding Conflict of Interest and Employee Abstention · Finding F1 and Recommendation R1

Civic question

What evidence would show that staff can safely report concerns and that consultant contracts deliver the promised work?

The jury recommends clearer reporting procedures and stronger controls over consultant engagement and review.
Why this matters
Accessible reporting and visible contract oversight can help safeguard public resources.

Supporting report

Parallels Between County Government and JCFHD · Findings F1–F2 and Recommendations R1–R2

Civic question

How should staff training and clear response procedures help residents follow the County’s engagement with grand jury recommendations?

The jury identifies training and invited-response concerns and recommends educational material and welcoming invited comments.
Why this matters
Residents should be able to distinguish agency positions, implementation promises, and unanswered issues.

Supporting report

Civil Grand Jury Access and Continuity · Continuity Report Findings F1–F2 and Recommendation R1

Civic question

How should the County prioritize written procedures, staff training, and handovers when employees change roles?

The jury recommends policy review, regular communication, overlapping staff transitions, and standardized training.
Why this matters
Consistent procedures can help residents receive dependable service despite staff turnover.

Supporting report

Workplace Culture, Training, and Organization · Findings F3–F4 and Recommendations R1–R5

Civic question

What milestones and staff support should guide the transition from legacy systems to Oracle and Tyler?

The jury links incomplete implementation to duplicate work and recommends a transition plan, adequate training, and fuller use of purchased systems.
Why this matters
Technology investments should reduce errors and improve service without disrupting essential work.

Supporting report

Continued Technology and Software Lessons · Findings F1–F4 and Recommendations R1–R4

Civic question

What should residents be able to learn about the status, priority, and resolution of a County complaint?

The jury recommends written code-enforcement procedures and uniform complaint-management standards.
Why this matters
A clear process helps residents understand whether their concerns have been received and what happens next.

Supporting report

Complaints and Code Compliance · Findings F1–F2 and Recommendations R1–R2

Civic question

How should Development Services explain permit requirements, staffing limits, and expected processing times?

The jury recommends public permitting resources, staffing action, clearer budget accounting, and consistent written procedures across departments.
Why this matters
Predictable permitting and timely environmental review affect safety, household plans, and local businesses.

Supporting report

Development Services · Findings F5–F6 and Recommendations R1–R6

Civic question

What public milestones should accompany annual audits and budget reviews so residents can understand financial risks early?

The jury identifies a delayed FY 2021–2022 audit and budget problems and calls for written audit procedures and regular financial reviews.
Why this matters
Residents need understandable financial information before spending decisions affect public services.

Supporting report

County Financial Roles and Fiscal Year 2023–2024 · Findings F1–F5 and Recommendations R1–R3

Civic question

How should road-maintenance priorities account for resident needs, visitor traffic, and limited funding?

The discussion compares road-condition goals with available maintenance funding and describes pressures associated with tourism.
Why this matters
Residents need to understand which road improvements limited funds can support and what tradeoffs remain.

Supporting report

Rural Disparity and State Reimbursements · Rural Disparity in Combination with State Reimbursements

Civic question

How can election staff explain ballot handling and verification while protecting voters’ private information?

The jury describes trained staff, separate ballot-processing duties, and courteous assistance, with no recommendations.
Why this matters
Clear explanations can support informed public confidence in election administration.

Supporting report

Observations of Elections · Observations of Elections and Finding F1

Civic question

How can conservation-camp training and community projects support both rehabilitation and local emergency readiness?

The jury describes wildfire and equipment training, community projects, and well-maintained facilities.
Why this matters
Skills and constructive work can benefit camp participants and the wider community.

Supporting report

Mt. Bullion Conservation Camp Facility Tour · Mt. Bullion Conservation Camp

Civic question

What milestones should guide HVAC replacement and improvements to cramped staff workspaces?

The jury recommends replacing necessary HVAC components and finding ways to maximize shared staff space.
Why this matters
Facility conditions affect people in custody, employees, visitors, and reliable public services.

Supporting report

Mariposa County Adult Detention Facility · Findings F1–F2 and Recommendations R1–R2

Sources

Original reports and response documents provide the evidence behind this cycle’s findings, recommendations, and discussions.

Response documents

Board response to workplace procedures and training · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFBoard and Auditor responses to fiscal oversight · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors and Mariposa County Auditor · PDFBoard and Auditor responses to technology transitions · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors and Mariposa County Auditor · PDFBoard response to complaint handling and code compliance · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFBoard response to Development Services · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFBoard response to director evaluations · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFBoard response to recusal procedures · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFCounty and Healthcare District responses to reporting and contracts · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors and John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors · PDFSheriff and Board responses to HVAC and office space · Mariposa County Sheriff's Office and Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFBoard response to grand-jury training and invited responses · Mariposa County Board of Supervisors · PDFHealthcare District response and later follow-up · John C. Fremont Healthcare District Board of Directors · PDF